7 min read

There Is No Market Rate

There Is No Market Rate
Photo by Moja Msanii / Unsplash

From January 2000 through December 2009, the S&P 500 returned an average of minus 0.95% a year. An investor who simply held "the market" for ten years lost money. Over the next ten years the same index more than tripled. Stretch the window to cover both decades and you get about 6% a year.

So which one was the market rate?

We ask because the phrase gets used as if it were a number you can look up in a book or on a chart, like the boiling point of water. A foundation board asks whether a deal is "market rate." A wealth advisor tells a family that anything below market rate is a concession. An impact fund promises "risk-adjusted, market-rate returns" to reassure the people writing checks. Every one of those sentences assumes there is a number out there, set by forces nobody controls, that every investment can and should be measured against.

There isn't one. Ask different people and you get different answers. In one widely cited study, venture capital funds earned an average of 11.6% a year, while impact funds in the same study earned 3.7%. Private equity firms that buy whole companies tell their investors to expect 20%. Change the years you measure or the kind of investment you compare against, and the "market" hands you a different number every time. Even big corporations don't use a market rate. Before approving a new project, they require it to earn a minimum return, and on average they set that bar around 15.7%, far above what it actually costs them to borrow or raise the money. The people closest to the market don't look up a rate. They pick the number they want.

Every "market rate" is built from two choices. The first is what to compare against: large American companies, global stocks, Treasury bonds, the top quarter of buyout funds. The second is the timeframe: the last ten years, the last thirty, since 1957. Change either choice and the number moves by whole percentage points. Then it gets quoted to one decimal place, as if it had been measured. That is false precision at its best: an arbitrary number dressed up as a fact.

Call it a benchmark rate

We have written before that "market rate" is code for maximum harm, and walked through how arbitrary the benchmarks behind it are: LIBOR, rigged and retired; GDP, built to measure war capacity and never welfare. That post argued the number is harmful, because hitting it depends on extraction. This one argues the number is made up, and looks at what the name does.

When you say "market rate," you hand the decision to an invisible crowd. Nobody chose it. It just is. When you say "benchmark rate," the next questions arrive on their own. Whose benchmark? Picked by whom? Measured over which years? Why that one and not another?

That is the honest description of what happens in every investment committee we have sat in. Someone selects an index. Someone writes a target into an Investment Policy Statement. Someone agrees to pay a fund manager to beat it. A benchmark rate is a choice, made by people, that can be made differently.

We have retired "market rate" from our own vocabulary. We don't use it. We invite you to do the same. If you still need the crutch of a comparison, call it a benchmark rate, and know what you are talking about. Know which index it is and which years it covers. Know what it is actually looking at. Does it price in the wages held down, the rents raised, the rivers polluted, the bankruptcies left behind? None of the standard ones do.

Turn the dial

Once you see the benchmark as a dial someone sets, the obvious question is what happens when they turn it up.

Picture one nursing home. Same building, same residents, same Medicare rates. Owned by a nonprofit, it needs to break even. Owned by a local family, maybe it needs 6%. Owned by a buyout fund that has promised its investors an 8% preferred return before the managers take their share, it needs far more than that, and fast. The residents did not change. The nurses did not change. Only the number did. Where does the difference come from?

Researchers have looked. When private equity bought nursing homes, short-stay residents' mortality rose 11%, by the most careful estimate, which the authors translate into roughly 22,500 additional deaths over twelve years. Front-line nursing assistant hours per patient fell. Interest payments rose more than 200%, and lease payments jumped after the buildings were sold out from under the operators. The harm to care quality was concentrated in the homes carrying the most financial liabilities. The money to pay the higher number came out of the staffing.

The same pattern shows up wherever someone has measured it. After buyouts of for-profit colleges, tuition rose about $1,600 and profits tripled, while graduation rates, loan repayment and graduates' earnings all fell. In hospitals bought by private equity, hospital-acquired conditions such as falls and infections rose 25% compared with similar hospitals. Large companies taken private through leveraged buyouts went bankrupt within ten years about 20% of the time. Similar companies that stayed public: 2%.

The most direct test of the dial is the dividend recapitalization, where owners borrow against a company they already own to pay themselves early. The owners take a bigger payout, sooner, and leave the company carrying the debt. A study of more than 61,000 buyouts found that recaps more than doubled the chance of financial distress over the next decade and drove down wage growth at the companies that survived. In our own research we matched three recaps at companies whose owners promote broad-based employee ownership: about $1.4 billion went to the owners. About $7 million went to the workers.

We want to be fair about what the research also shows. When private equity buys a small private company and helps it grow, employment often rises, by 13% in one large Census study, and productivity improves. A high return can come from building something real. But notice where the harm clusters: in the deals where owners took the most, the fastest, through debt, fees, and sold-off real estate. That is the dial turned to its highest setting.

No one has charted return targets across the whole economy against harm to workers, customers, communities and the planet. What exists is narrower and, we think, more convincing: study after study, in nursing homes, hospitals, colleges and buyouts, where the owners demanding more are followed by the people inside getting less. Higher leverage, faster payouts and bigger fees keep showing up next to lower staffing, lower wages, higher prices and more bankruptcies.

So we won't tell you that every extra point of return is taken from someone. Some of it is earned. What we will say is this: the higher you set the benchmark, the fewer equitable ways there are to reach it, and the more the remaining ways depend on someone with less power paying the difference. The burden of proof belongs on the higher number.

Write your number down

Which raises a harder question. If the benchmark is a choice, what is it actually for? We think the honest answer is comfort, and sales. A benchmark lets an investor glance at a quarterly report and feel they did well or poorly without having to ask whether the money was made by building something or by extracting it from others. It gives an advisor or a fund manager a pitch: we beat the benchmark. It measures one return against another return, picked by the people being measured. It tells you nothing about where either one came from.

Take Mission Driven Finance, a firm we invest in. Its Care Access Real Estate trust buys houses and leases them to home child care providers at rents they can afford, with the option to buy after two years. Could it make investors more? Yes. It could charge whatever the local market will bear and keep the houses as they appreciate. But the extra return would come straight out of the providers' income, and then out of the number of child care spots in the neighborhood. No benchmark shows that trade.

You will still have a number somewhere in your paperwork. The point is to stop pretending someone else set it.

So here is what we would rather measure against: a fully loaded benchmark. Accountants already know the idea. A fully loaded cost counts everything a thing really costs, not just the sticker price. A fully loaded benchmark would do the same for returns. Start with the financial return, then subtract what the companies behind it pushed onto everyone else: the wages held down, the rent hikes, the carbon, the bankruptcies.

Some of that bill has already been priced. In 2013 the firm Trucost, working for a UN-backed program, put the top environmental costs of the world's primary industries at about $7.3 trillion a year, roughly 13% of global output. Of the 20 industry-regions with the largest impacts, none would have turned a profit if it had paid those costs. What should have happened? Those costs belonged on the companies' books, where they would have wiped out the profit. Instead the public paid them, and the profit went into the returns everyone now benchmarks against. Load that into a benchmark and "beating the market" starts to mean something very different.

We don't have the full math yet. Nobody does. But a rough number that counts the whole bill is more honest than a precise one that leaves half of it out.

If you manage money for a foundation, a family or a donor-advised fund, there is already a benchmark rate written somewhere in your paperwork. Go find it. Then ask three questions about it.

Who chose this number, and when? If the answer is "it's just the market," someone chose it and didn't tell you why.

What would a business have to do to pay us this much, year after year, without cutting wages, raising prices on people who can't walk away, or borrowing against its own future? If nobody can answer, that is an answer.

What could we fund if we set it two or three points lower? Investors in impact funds already accept about that much, according to the same researchers who measured the gap. Some of the capital is already willing. What's missing is the honesty to name the trade.

We are still working this out in our own portfolio. We have made our own portfolio mistakes. When we moved our money into community lenders and employee ownership, including Unlock Ownership, we wrote down a different number on purpose. It's ours, and we can tell you why we picked it.

The market doesn't set your rate. You do. Pick one you could explain to the people who pay it.